What is a perfect crime?

“The perfect crime is when the victim forgets they were ever robbed.”

"What is a perfect crime?" As strange as this question sounds, its answer is equally meaningful. This question is similar to the root of this whole collection, in relation to which some people think, "A perfect crime can be one where no evidence of the crime is found." Looking a little further, "A perfect crime may be one that no one even knows about." But beyond even this, the biggest problem is that "after the crime has occurred, no one should even feel that a crime has been committed". Perhaps… the same thing happened to us. Before understanding this, let us first look at a letter written by Max Müller to Bairam Malbari:

You accept the Veda as an ancient historical text, which describes the thoughts of the people of an ancient and simple character. Then you will be able to appreciate it and be able to accept some of it, especially in today’s era also the teachings of the Upanishads... But you find in it steam engines and electricity, European philosophy and morality, and you take away from it its true nature. You destroy its true values and you destroy its historical continuity that has been linking the present with its past. (29/01/1882)

Black and white line art showing a nineteenth-century intellectual discussion between Max Müller and Bairam Malabari in a scholarly setting.

This paper was published after Max Müller's death by his wife, Georgia Max Müller. She published more such letters, which clearly reflected the Christian teaching of the British authorities and the tampering with Indian texts. In the name of translation, the originals of the texts were altered to suit English interpretations — an example of which is found in this verse of the Rigveda:

Yunjanti Vrangham Charantam Paritasthushah Rochante Rachanadivi. (R. 1.6.1)

In this verse, the meaning of Vrangham was taken as “horse” in the English translation, whereas its real meaning refers to God. This was done not only to degrade Indian texts but also to sever their influence from their originals. Because no nation can be completely ruled as long as its culture is alive among its people. This was a matter of concern for the British Government, which is clearly visible in another letter by Max Müller to the Secretary of the State, the Duke of Argyll:

India has been won once. But India must be won again, and this second victory must be through Christian education. Recently, much has been done for education, but if this amount is doubled or quadrupled, then it will not be difficult to do. The Christianity of India may not be like our nineteenth-century Christianity, but the ancient religion of India has sunk here; yet, if Christianity does not spread here, then whose fault will it be? (16/12/1868)

The Silent Victory of Colonial Education

It is unfortunate that the credit for modern education in India is given to Macaulay, who described “a single line from a book in a European library as more valuable than the priceless heritage of India.” At the same time, Max Müller's educational design, which gave rise to false ideas like the "Aryan theory", was made the foundation of ancient Indian history. It was a victory for the British government over the Indian education system — a victory that still influences us even after independence. There is hardly any better or more successful definition of a Perfect Crime than this, one that has been written in golden letters in the pages of our history… and yet remains invisible to most of us.

“

Perhaps the most perfect crime in history was not committed against our land, but against our memory—so flawlessly that even its victims forgot they had been robbed. – Rishabh Bhatt

”

Incompleteness At Every Turn book by Rishabh Bhatt exploring human emotions, life struggles, self-discovery, and philosophical reflections

STORY SOURCE

This story is adapted from “Incompleteness At Every Turn”

"Incompleteness At Every Turn" is a book about life’s unfinished stories, deep feelings, and the beauty of being imperfect. Instead of happy fairy-tale endings, it shows real life—moments of love, loss, hope, and healing that do not always have a perfect answer. Written in a simple yet touching way, the author shows that it is okay to feel incomplete. In fact, our incomplete parts are what help us grow, learn, and keep moving forward every day.

Buy Book 🛒 Read More

Written by